Executive Summary
This judgment concerns Ernst & Young LLP’s (EY) application to lift confidentiality restrictions on a settlement agreement and related documents ("Bin Butti Claim Documents") involving NMC Health PLC (in administration) and the Bin Butti family, linked to UAE bankruptcy proceedings. The English Commercial Court balanced English procedural law against UAE confidentiality and criminal law risks. The Court recognized EY’s right to access documents for fair litigation but noted ongoing UAE court controls on disclosure. The case highlights complex cross-jurisdictional tensions involving sanctions, confidentiality, and insolvency.
Sanctions Highlights
- The Settlement Agreement involves claims totaling approximately USD 9.66 billion (AED 35.5 billion) between NMC entities and the Bin Buttis, who are UAE nationals.
- No explicit sanctions are imposed on the Bin Buttis or NMC in the judgment, but the case implicates sensitive financial disclosures subject to UAE bankruptcy law and potential foreign criminal law risks.
- EY argues no clear evidence exists that disclosure would breach UAE law or sanctions regimes; the Settlement Agreement expressly allows disclosure in legal proceedings.
- The Court must balance English discovery rules with potential foreign sanctions or criminal prosecution risks, referencing *Bank Mellat v HM Treasury* (2019) on jurisdiction despite foreign law conflicts.
Emerging Risks
- Risk of prosecution under UAE law remains a key concern for NMC and its administrators if disclosure breaches local confidentiality or criminal statutes.
- The ongoing administration and bankruptcy proceedings in the UAE and ADGM free zone create legal uncertainty for multinational entities operating in the region.
- Potential reputational and financial risks for parties involved if confidential settlement terms become public or misused.
- The case underscores risks in cross-border insolvency involving jurisdictions with differing legal standards on confidentiality and sanctions compliance.
Geopolitical Impact
- The dispute involves entities and courts in the UK, UAE (Abu Dhabi Global Market), and indirectly implicates US dollar-denominated claims, highlighting transnational legal complexity.
- The UAE’s ADGM court’s involvement reflects the jurisdiction’s growing role as a regional financial and legal hub, balancing local law with international litigation norms.
- UK courts assert procedural primacy but show deference to UAE bankruptcy court orders, illustrating ongoing judicial comity tensions between Western and Gulf legal systems.
- The case may influence future UK-UAE cooperation on insolvency, sanctions enforcement, and cross-border financial disputes.
Economic Intelligence
- NMC Health PLC was a London-listed healthcare group with extensive UAE operations, now in administration since April 2020, reflecting sectoral vulnerabilities.
- The USD 9.66 billion claim and settlement reflect significant financial exposure linked to the Bin Buttis and related entities, indicating large-scale corporate restructuring and asset recovery efforts.
- The case highlights risks for auditors (EY) and financial institutions in managing disclosure and compliance amid complex insolvency and sanctions environments.
- The ongoing administration and bankruptcy proceedings may impact investor confidence and cross-border capital flows in the UAE healthcare and financial sectors.
Strategic Recommendations
- Parties should maintain strict confidentiality protocols while preparing for phased disclosure under court supervision to mitigate foreign prosecution risks.
- Legal teams must closely monitor UAE bankruptcy court rulings and coordinate with English courts to manage disclosure timing and scope.
- Risk assessments should incorporate potential sanctions and criminal law implications in both jurisdictions, with contingency plans for reputational and financial fallout.
- Stakeholders should engage with regional legal experts to navigate ADGM and UAE insolvency frameworks and anticipate evolving cross-border enforcement trends.
- Consider leveraging confidentiality clubs with clear membership and access rules to balance transparency and protection of sensitive information.
---
**Source Notes:** *Sanctions Intelligence Digest* — [NMC Health PLC v Ernst & Young LLP (2025) EWHC 1048 (Comm)](https://empyreanprotocol.com/litigation/view/www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Comm/2025/1048