Executive Summary
- The case concerns AmTrust Europe Ltd’s claims against MD Insurance Services Ltd (MDIS) and its subsidiaries MD Warranty Inspection Services Ltd (MDWIS) and MD Warranty Support Services Ltd (MDWSS) for negligence and breach of duty in underwriting and claims handling of latent defect insurance policies.
- MDIS acted as coverholder under a Binding Authority Agreement ("Binder") with AmTrust, managing insurance schemes aimed at new property developers.
- MDWIS and MDWSS conducted property surveys as a condition precedent for issuing insurance policies.
- The dispute centers on whether MDIS and its subsidiaries owed a duty of care to AmTrust and the adequacy of their underwriting and claims handling.
- The court considered applications to amend claims, add defendants, and for summary judgment.
Sanctions Highlights
- No sanctions implications identified in the case.
Emerging Risks
- Potential limitation issues arising from amendments to the Particulars of Claim.
- Uncertainty over the contractual chain and scope of duties owed by MDIS and its subsidiaries.
- Risk of liability for surveyors (MDWIS/MDWSS) in issuing Certificates of Approval that enable insurance issuance.
- Possible reputational and financial exposure for insurers relying on third-party administrators and surveyors.
Geopolitical Impact
- The case is adjudicated in the England and Wales High Court, reflecting UK jurisdiction over insurance and commercial disputes.
- Highlights the regulatory and legal environment in the UK governing insurance underwriting and delegated authority arrangements.
- Reinforces the importance of clear contractual frameworks in UK insurance markets, especially for latent defect insurance linked to property development.
Economic Intelligence
- The dispute involves significant latent defect insurance schemes (Premier Guarantee, LABC Warranty) critical to UK property development and mortgage markets.
- Potential financial exposure for AmTrust and associated entities due to alleged inadequate underwriting and claims handling.
- The outcome may influence underwriting practices and risk management in UK property insurance sectors.
- Could impact the role and liability of coverholders and surveyors in delegated insurance authority models.
Strategic Recommendations
- Insurers should ensure robust contractual clarity and risk allocation with coverholders and surveyors.
- Regular review and updating of Scheme Documents and Binding Authority Agreements to mitigate ambiguity.
- Enhanced oversight and quality control of surveyor certifications to reduce latent defect risks.
- Monitor legal developments in UK insurance duty of care and delegated authority jurisprudence.
- Consider potential limitation periods carefully when amending claims or adding parties in litigation.
---
**Source Notes:**
Sanctions Intelligence Digest — [https://empyreanprotocol.com/litigation/view/www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Comm/2025/1468.txt](https://empyreanprotocol.com/litigation/view/www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Comm/2025/1468.txt)