Executive Summary
This case concerns a professional negligence claim by Watford Community Housing Trust against Arthur J Gallagher Insurance Brokers Ltd for failing to timely notify two insurers (QBE and Hiscox) of a 2020 data breach. The Defendant broker admits negligence but argues no loss was caused due to double insurance provisions limiting total indemnity. The Claimant was insured under three policies: Cyber Policy (£1M limit), Combined Policy (£5M limit), and PI Policy (£5M limit). QBE initially declined cover but later indemnified the Claimant; Hiscox maintained its declinature. The key legal issue is whether the “other insurance” clauses reduce the Claimant’s recoverable indemnity below the total losses incurred.
Sanctions Highlights
— No sanctions implications identified in this litigation.
Emerging Risks
- Potential for uncovered liability exceeding £6 million due to exhausted Cyber and eroded QBE cover.
- Risk of further claims until limitation period expires in March 2026.
- Uncertainty over interpretation of “other insurance” clauses may affect future claims involving multiple overlapping policies.
- Possible precedent for limiting indemnity recoveries in cases of multiple insurance policies with conflicting excess and non-contribution clauses.
Geopolitical Impact
- The case involves insurers and brokers operating under UK law, with implications for insurance markets in the UK, Canada, and the United States where similar multi-policy arrangements and data breach exposures are common.
- The judgment may influence cross-border insurance litigation strategies and broker liability standards in these jurisdictions.
Economic Intelligence
- The Claimant’s potential uncovered losses could exceed £6 million, impacting financial stability of insured entities facing large-scale data breaches.
- Insurers’ interpretation of “other insurance” clauses may limit aggregate payouts, affecting claims reserves and underwriting practices.
- Brokers’ negligence in notification processes could increase professional liability claims and insurance costs.
- The case highlights the economic significance of clear policy drafting and timely claims management in cyber and professional indemnity insurance sectors.
Strategic Recommendations
- Insured entities should review all overlapping insurance policies for “other insurance” clauses and notification requirements to avoid coverage gaps.
- Brokers must implement rigorous compliance and notification protocols to mitigate negligence risks.
- Insurers should clarify policy language on excess and non-contribution to reduce litigation risk.
- Legal teams should monitor this case for precedent on double insurance interpretation affecting indemnity limits.
- Risk managers should prepare for potential uncovered losses beyond policy limits in complex multi-policy claims.
---
Source Notes: *Sanctions Intelligence Digest* — https://empyreanprotocol.com/litigation/view/www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Comm/2025/743.txt